{"schemaVersion":"1.0","generatedAt":"2026-09-22","data":{"schemaVersion":"1.0","generatedAt":"2026-09-22","evidenceClasses":[{"class":"scientific","label":"Scientific evidence","definition":"Supported by registered peer-reviewed research or scientific review literature.","requiresSource":true,"verified":true},{"class":"historical","label":"Historical evidence","definition":"Supported by a registered historical record or archive source.","requiresSource":true,"verified":true},{"class":"cultural","label":"Cultural description","definition":"A description of how a smell is commonly perceived, named or associated. It can vary by person and culture.","requiresSource":false,"verified":false},{"class":"editorial","label":"Editorial interpretation","definition":"A SmellBook editorial decision, such as a classification, a link between entries or a curated list.","requiresSource":false,"verified":false},{"class":"community","label":"Community observation","definition":"A contribution or observation from the public. It never becomes scientific fact automatically.","requiresSource":false,"verified":false},{"class":"predicted","label":"Experimental / predicted","definition":"A computed or experimental candidate relation, published only in Labs. PREDICTED is never VERIFIED.","requiresSource":false,"verified":false}],"provenanceBasisClass":{"profile-related-field":"editorial","editorial-comparison":"editorial","profile-descriptor-field":"cultural","curated-descriptor-list":"cultural","curated-category-list":"editorial","curated-type-list":"editorial","curated-context-list":"editorial","claim-record":"editorial","editorial-place-material-mapping":"editorial","editorial-entry-setting":"editorial","editorial-entry-description":"editorial","heritage-identity-record":"editorial","editorial-entry-identity":"editorial","editorial-origin-record":"editorial"},"sourceKindClass":{"PRIMARY RESEARCH":"scientific","REVIEW":"scientific","HISTORICAL RECORD":"historical","ARCHIVE":"historical"},"claimEvidence":[{"claimId":"CLM-PETRICHOR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PETRICHOR-1964"]},{"claimId":"CLM-OLDBOOK-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-OLDBOOK-2009"]},{"claimId":"CLM-COFFEE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COFFEE-2022"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GREEN-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GLV-2022"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CITRUS-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CITRUS-2019"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MANGO-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MANGO-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PINEAPPLE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PINEAPPLE-2023"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GINGER-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GINGER-2017"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PEPPER-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PEPPER-2019"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CARAMEL-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CARAMEL-1994"]},{"claimId":"CLM-RICE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-RICE-2008"]},{"claimId":"CLM-WOODSMOKE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-WOODSMOKE-2025"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BREAD-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-BREAD-2010"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CHOCOLATE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CHOCOLATE-2020"]},{"claimId":"CLM-VANILLA-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-VANILLA-2011"]},{"claimId":"CLM-STRAWBERRY-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-STRAWBERRY-2023"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BANANA-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-BANANA-2018"]},{"claimId":"CLM-APPLE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-APPLE-2025"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BUTTER-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-BUTTER-2007"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CHEDDAR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CHEDDAR-2021"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BLACKTEA-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-BLACKTEA-2022"]},{"claimId":"CLM-COCONUT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COCONUT-1984"]},{"claimId":"CLM-POPCORN-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-POPCORN-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MUSHROOM-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MUSHROOM-2024"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GARLIC-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GARLIC-2019"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PEACH-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PEACH-2022"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MILK-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MILK-2024"]},{"claimId":"CLM-VINEGAR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-VINEGAR-2020"]},{"claimId":"CLM-WATERMELON-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-WATERMELON-2018"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BROWNSUGAR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-BROWNSUGAR-2021"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ROSE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ROSE-2025"]},{"claimId":"CLM-JASMINE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-JASMINE-2017"]},{"claimId":"CLM-LAVENDER-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-LAVENDER-2025"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GARDENIA-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GARDENIA-2024"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MINT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MINT-2021"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BASIL-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-BASIL-2023"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ROSEMARY-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ROSEMARY-2017"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SAGE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-SAGE-2023"]},{"claimId":"CLM-THYME-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-THYME-2021"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CINNAMON-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CINNAMON-2022"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CLOVE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CLOVE-2021"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PINENEEDLE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PINENEEDLE-2024"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PINERESIN-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PINERESIN-2026"]},{"claimId":"CLM-NEWCAR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-NEWCAR-2022"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GASOLINE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GASOLINE-2025"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PLASTIC-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PLASTIC-2023"]},{"claimId":"CLM-OAK-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-OAK-2024"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PINEWOOD-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PINEWOOD-2023"]},{"claimId":"CLM-INCENSECEDAR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-INCENSECEDAR-2017"]},{"claimId":"CLM-LAUNDRY-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-LAUNDRY-2020"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MUSEUM-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MUSEUM-2026"]},{"claimId":"CLM-FRANKINCENSE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-FRANKINCENSE-2015"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HISTORICBOOK-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-HISTORICBOOK-2017"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CARDBOARD-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CARDBOARD-2009"]},{"claimId":"CLM-NEWCARODOUR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-NEWCARODOUR-2022"]},{"claimId":"CLM-POLYURETHANE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-POLYURETHANE-2024"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ONION-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ONION-2004"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HONEY-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-HONEY-2011"]},{"claimId":"CLM-YOGURT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-YOGURT-2010"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PEANUT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PEANUT-2010"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ALMOND-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ALMOND-2017"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ALMOND-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ALMOND-2017"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ORANGEJUICE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ORANGEJUICE-2008"]},{"claimId":"CLM-COCOA-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COCOA-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GRAPE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GRAPE-2000"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CHERRY-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CHERRY-2014"]},{"claimId":"CLM-NUTMEG-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-NUTMEG-2015"]},{"claimId":"CLM-TOMATOPASTE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-TOMATOPASTE-1990"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PEAR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PEAR-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-LILAC-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-LILAC-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SEAWEED-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-SEAWEED-2023"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SKIN-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-SKIN-2008"]},{"claimId":"CLM-RUBBER-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-RUBBER-2019"]},{"claimId":"CLM-LEATHER-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-LEATHER-2025"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CANDLE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CANDLE-2015"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CARPET-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CARPET-1993"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BREAD-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-VALENCIA-BREAD-2024"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GARLIC-002","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-LEMOINNE-1858"]},{"claimId":"CLM-INCENSE-002","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-BARRACA-1901"]},{"claimId":"CLM-POOL-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-POOL-2011"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CLEANING-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CLEANING-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-FIREPLACE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-FIREPLACE-2001"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ASPHALT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ASPHALT-2020"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CABIN-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CABIN-2007"]},{"claimId":"CLM-NEWAPARTMENT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-NEWAPARTMENT-2013"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PAINT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PAINT-1996"]},{"claimId":"CLM-OFFICE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-OFFICE-2000"]},{"claimId":"CLM-LEAFLITTER-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-LEAFLITTER-2002"]},{"claimId":"CLM-OFFICEPAPER-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-OFFICEPAPER-2026"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CHAMOMILE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CHAMOMILE-2010"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GRAPEFRUIT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GRAPEFRUIT-2005"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MAPLE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MAPLE-2009"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ICECREAM-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ICECREAM-2003"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CURRY-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CURRY-2016"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PEPPERMINT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PEPPERMINT-2010"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MENTHOL-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MENTHOL-2013"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HANDRUB-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-HANDRUB-2012"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HOSPITAL-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-HOSPITAL-2013"]},{"claimId":"CLM-FRAGRANCE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COSMETICS-2011"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GARDEN-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GARDEN-2021"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GRILLING-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GRILLING-2020"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PINEFOREST-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CONIFERS-2013"]},{"claimId":"CLM-EUCALYPTUS-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-EUCALYPTUS-2018"]},{"claimId":"CLM-COMPUTERS-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COMPUTERS-2004"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SAWMILL-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-SAWMILL-2002"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MOSS-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MOSS-2001"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CLASSROOM-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CLASSROOM-2008"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GARAGE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GARAGE-2007"]},{"claimId":"CLM-STABLE-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-NORDHOFF-1880"]},{"claimId":"CLM-METAL-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-PSM-1898"]},{"claimId":"CLM-EUCALYPTUS-002","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-BENTLEY-1874"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SNOW-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-ADOBEDAYS-1926"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CELLAR-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-ADOBEDAYS-1926"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SEAAIR-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-GAUTIER-1845"]},{"claimId":"CLM-OLDCHURCH-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-MERCIER-1782"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HARDWARE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-HARDWARE-2025"]},{"claimId":"CLM-IRON-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-IRON-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SWEETCORN-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-SWEETCORN-1974"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HAYDRYING-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GRASSDRYING-1999"]},{"claimId":"CLM-TOASTING-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-TOASTING-2020"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CORK-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CORK-2020"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PHARMACYAIR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-INDOORVOC-2008"]},{"claimId":"CLM-TAXI-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-TAXI-2019"]},{"claimId":"CLM-COMMUTE-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COMMUTE-2003"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SALON-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-SALON-2018"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SUNSCREEN-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-SUNSCREEN-2022"]},{"claimId":"CLM-FRIEDONION-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ONION-1975"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PARKING-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PARKING-2023"]},{"claimId":"CLM-DISHWASHER-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-DISHWASHER-1999"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HAY-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-EB1911-HAY"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BAKEHOUSE-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-WYNTER-1863"]},{"claimId":"CLM-UNDERGROUND-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-FRISWELL-1862"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BEDSHEETS-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-MACAULAY-1876"]},{"claimId":"CLM-IRONING-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-DICKENS-1839"]},{"claimId":"CLM-FLOWERMARKET-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-OBER-1884"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HOTELROOM-001","evidenceClass":"historical","sourceIds":["SRC-WHARTON-1922"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GEOSMIN-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GEOSMIN-1965","SRC-GEOSMIN-2007"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CHOCOLATE-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-DARKCHOCOLATE-2002"]},{"claimId":"CLM-VANILLA-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-VANILLA-2013"]},{"claimId":"CLM-COCOA-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COCOA-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GINGER-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-GINGER-2017"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MANGO-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MANGO-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-OLDBOOK-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-OLDBOOK-2009"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BROWNSUGAR-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-BROWNSUGAR-2021"]},{"claimId":"CLM-TRAINCAR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-RAILCAR-2024"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ORANGEPEEL-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ORANGEPEEL-2008"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ROSE-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ROSE-2019"]},{"claimId":"CLM-LAVENDER-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-LAVENDER-2017"]},{"claimId":"CLM-MINT-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-MINTSPECIES-2022"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PEPPERMINT-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PEPPERMINT-2021"]},{"claimId":"CLM-SAGE-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-SAGE-2021"]},{"claimId":"CLM-THYME-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-THYME-2005"]},{"claimId":"CLM-PEPPER-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-PEPPER-2002"]},{"claimId":"CLM-COFFEE-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COFFEEGRINDING-2003"]},{"claimId":"CLM-APPLE-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-APPLE-2020"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HONEY-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-HONEY-2012"]},{"claimId":"CLM-POPCORN-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-POPCORN-1991"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CARAMEL-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CARAMEL-2014"]},{"claimId":"CLM-CORK-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-CORKSTOPPERS-2009"]},{"claimId":"CLM-GARLIC-003","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COOKEDGARLIC-1993"]},{"claimId":"CLM-HAIR-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-SCALP-2018"]},{"claimId":"CLM-COFFEESHOP-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COFFEECAFES-2020"]},{"claimId":"CLM-DETERGENT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-DRYERVENT-2018"]},{"claimId":"CLM-COFFEE-003","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-COFFEEODORANTS-1999"]},{"claimId":"CLM-BERGAMOT-001","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-BERGAMOT-2006"]},{"claimId":"CLM-ROSEMARY-002","evidenceClass":"scientific","sourceIds":["SRC-ROSEMARYODOUR-2026"]}],"contributionReviewModel":{"live":false,"writeApi":false,"states":[{"state":"SUBMITTED","terminal":false,"evidenceClass":null,"meaning":"Received; not public."},{"state":"UNDER_REVIEW","terminal":false,"evidenceClass":null,"meaning":"Being checked by an editor; not public."},{"state":"COMMUNITY_OBSERVATION","terminal":true,"evidenceClass":"community","meaning":"Published as a labelled community observation."},{"state":"EDITORIALLY_REVIEWED","terminal":true,"evidenceClass":"editorial","meaning":"Accepted into editorial content after review."},{"state":"SOURCE_VERIFIED","terminal":true,"evidenceClass":"scientific-or-historical","meaning":"Checked against a registered source; requires the source to be registered first."},{"state":"REJECTED","terminal":true,"evidenceClass":null,"meaning":"Not published."},{"state":"WITHDRAWN","terminal":true,"evidenceClass":null,"meaning":"Withdrawn by the contributor; not published."}],"transitions":[["SUBMITTED","UNDER_REVIEW"],["SUBMITTED","WITHDRAWN"],["UNDER_REVIEW","COMMUNITY_OBSERVATION"],["UNDER_REVIEW","EDITORIALLY_REVIEWED"],["UNDER_REVIEW","SOURCE_VERIFIED"],["UNDER_REVIEW","REJECTED"],["COMMUNITY_OBSERVATION","UNDER_REVIEW"]],"rules":["Every transition is an explicit editorial action; no state changes automatically.","COMMUNITY_OBSERVATION never becomes SOURCE_VERIFIED directly; it must return to UNDER_REVIEW and be checked against a registered source.","Only SOURCE_VERIFIED contributions may carry the scientific or historical evidence class.","PREDICTED material from Labs is not a contribution and never enters this pipeline as verified."]},"contributionReviewRules":{"live":false,"writeApi":false,"kinds":["local-name","translation","smell-memory","historical-reference","correction","missing-smell","photograph","smellscape-observation","heritage-reference"],"transitionRoles":{"SUBMITTED->UNDER_REVIEW":["editor","reviewer"],"SUBMITTED->WITHDRAWN":["contributor"],"UNDER_REVIEW->COMMUNITY_OBSERVATION":["reviewer"],"UNDER_REVIEW->EDITORIALLY_REVIEWED":["reviewer"],"UNDER_REVIEW->SOURCE_VERIFIED":["evidence-reviewer"],"UNDER_REVIEW->REJECTED":["reviewer"],"COMMUNITY_OBSERVATION->UNDER_REVIEW":["editor","reviewer"]},"checks":["Every transition is a recorded decision by a named person with a date; nothing changes automatically.","No one reviews, accepts or rejects their own contribution; only the contributor may withdraw it.","Each decision belongs to a role: editors and reviewers open review, reviewers accept or reject, evidence reviewers verify against sources.","SOURCE_VERIFIED requires at least one registered source whose kind supports scientific or historical evidence; the contribution takes that class.","A rejection records a reason.","Labs or predicted material is not a contribution and never enters the pipeline."]}}}