{"schemaVersion":"1.0","generatedAt":"2026-09-22","data":{"checkedOn":"2026-10-02","methods":{"phrase-in-abstract":"The statement the claim rests on was found word for word in the abstract fetched from the named service, and an editor read the full abstract against every part of the claim.","read-against-abstract":"An editor read the abstract fetched from the named service against every part of the claim.","read-on-publisher-page":"No service holds the abstract and the publisher blocks automated fetching; two independent readings of the abstract on the publisher's page agreed on the statement the claim rests on.","corrected-to-abstract":"An editor read the abstract, found the claim said more than it supports, and narrowed the claim; the correction notice records what changed.","passage-in-page-text":"The statement the claim rests on was found word for word in the text of the cited page or chapter of the digitised source, fetched from the named service, and an editor read that whole text against every part of the claim. The passage is cited by its locator; SmellBook does not reproduce the passage.","no-abstract-available":"Neither Crossref, Europe PMC nor the publisher's page provides an abstract, so the claim has not been checked against the source's own summary."},"services":{"crossref":"Crossref (api.crossref.org)","openalex":"OpenAlex (api.openalex.org), abstract rebuilt word for word from its word index","europepmc":"Europe PMC (ebi.ac.uk/europepmc)","publisher-page":"the publisher's page, fetched by an automated check","wikisource":"Wikisource (transcription of the page)","internet-archive":"Internet Archive (OCR text of the page)","gallica":"Gallica, Bibliothèque nationale de France (OCR text of the page)"},"summary":{"claims":166,"byMethod":{"phrase-in-abstract":135,"read-against-abstract":4,"read-on-publisher-page":2,"corrected-to-abstract":7,"passage-in-page-text":16,"no-abstract-available":2}},"records":[{"claimId":"CLM-POOL-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CLEANING-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-FIREPLACE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-ASPHALT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CABIN-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-NEWAPARTMENT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PAINT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-OFFICE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-LEAFLITTER-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-OFFICEPAPER-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CHAMOMILE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GRAPEFRUIT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-MAPLE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-ICECREAM-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CURRY-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PEPPERMINT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-MENTHOL-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-HANDRUB-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-HOSPITAL-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-FRAGRANCE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GARDEN-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GRILLING-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PINEFOREST-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-EUCALYPTUS-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-COMPUTERS-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SAWMILL-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-MOSS-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CLASSROOM-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GARAGE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-STABLE-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-METAL-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-EUCALYPTUS-002","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SNOW-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CELLAR-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SEAAIR-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-OLDCHURCH-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GARLIC-002","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-INCENSE-002","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BREAD-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-RUBBER-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-LEATHER-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CANDLE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CARPET-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-LILAC-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SEAWEED-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SKIN-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-ONION-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-HONEY-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-YOGURT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PEANUT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-ALMOND-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-ALMOND-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-ORANGEJUICE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-COCOA-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GRAPE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CHERRY-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-NUTMEG-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-TOMATOPASTE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PEAR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-APPLE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BANANA-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BASIL-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BLACKTEA-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BREAD-001","method":"read-on-publisher-page","abstractSource":null,"correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BROWNSUGAR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BUTTER-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CARAMEL-001","method":"no-abstract-available","abstractSource":null,"correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CARDBOARD-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CHEDDAR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CHOCOLATE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CINNAMON-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CITRUS-001","method":"corrected-to-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":"COR-0007"},{"claimId":"CLM-CLOVE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-COCONUT-001","method":"read-against-abstract","abstractSource":"publisher-page","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-COFFEE-001","method":"corrected-to-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":"COR-0001"},{"claimId":"CLM-FRANKINCENSE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GARDENIA-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GARLIC-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GASOLINE-001","method":"read-on-publisher-page","abstractSource":null,"correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GINGER-001","method":"corrected-to-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":"COR-0010"},{"claimId":"CLM-GREEN-001","method":"corrected-to-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":"COR-0002"},{"claimId":"CLM-HISTORICBOOK-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-INCENSECEDAR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-JASMINE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-LAUNDRY-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-LAVENDER-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-MANGO-001","method":"corrected-to-abstract","abstractSource":"openalex","correctionId":"COR-0008"},{"claimId":"CLM-MILK-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-MINT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-MUSEUM-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-MUSHROOM-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-NEWCAR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-NEWCARODOUR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-OAK-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-OLDBOOK-001","method":"read-against-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PEACH-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PEPPER-001","method":"corrected-to-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":"COR-0003"},{"claimId":"CLM-PETRICHOR-001","method":"no-abstract-available","abstractSource":null,"correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PINEAPPLE-001","method":"read-against-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PINENEEDLE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PINERESIN-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PINEWOOD-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PLASTIC-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-POLYURETHANE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-POPCORN-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-RICE-001","method":"corrected-to-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":"COR-0009"},{"claimId":"CLM-ROSE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-ROSEMARY-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SAGE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-STRAWBERRY-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-THYME-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-VANILLA-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-VINEGAR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-WATERMELON-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-WOODSMOKE-001","method":"read-against-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-HARDWARE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"openalex","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-IRON-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"openalex","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SWEETCORN-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-HAYDRYING-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"crossref","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-TOASTING-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CORK-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PHARMACYAIR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-TAXI-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-COMMUTE-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SALON-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SUNSCREEN-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-FRIEDONION-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PARKING-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-DISHWASHER-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"openalex","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-HAY-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BAKEHOUSE-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BEDSHEETS-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-IRONING-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-FLOWERMARKET-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-HOTELROOM-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-COFFEESHOP-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null,"checkedOn":"2026-10-24"},{"claimId":"CLM-DETERGENT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"openalex","correctionId":null,"checkedOn":"2026-10-24"},{"claimId":"CLM-COFFEE-003","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null,"checkedOn":"2026-10-25"},{"claimId":"CLM-BERGAMOT-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"openalex","correctionId":null,"checkedOn":"2026-10-25"},{"claimId":"CLM-ROSEMARY-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null,"checkedOn":"2026-10-25"},{"claimId":"CLM-UNDERGROUND-001","method":"passage-in-page-text","abstractSource":"wikisource","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GEOSMIN-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CHOCOLATE-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-VANILLA-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-COCOA-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GINGER-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-MANGO-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"openalex","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-OLDBOOK-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-BROWNSUGAR-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-TRAINCAR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-ORANGEPEEL-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-ROSE-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-LAVENDER-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-MINT-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PEPPERMINT-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-SAGE-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-THYME-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-PEPPER-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-COFFEE-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-APPLE-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-HONEY-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-POPCORN-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CARAMEL-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-CORK-002","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-GARLIC-003","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null},{"claimId":"CLM-HAIR-001","method":"phrase-in-abstract","abstractSource":"europepmc","correctionId":null}],"unchecked":["CLM-CARAMEL-001","CLM-PETRICHOR-001"],"boundary":"A support check confirms that the source's own summary supports the claim as SmellBook words it. It does not assess the quality of the research, and an abstract can omit detail found in the full text."}}