{"schemaVersion":"1.0","generatedAt":"2026-09-22","data":{"schemaVersion":"1.0","generatedAt":"2026-09-22","auditVersion":"1.0","reviewedOn":"2026-10-04","boundary":"This report lists facts about each published entry and the result of each audit check. It gives no score, grade or ranking, and a finding is not a judgement of the smell itself. A finding resolved as kept was read by an editor and found accurate; deferred findings are recorded for editorial follow-up; open questions wait for a decision rather than being guessed.","checks":[{"id":"entry-standard","area":"Structure","rule":"The entry meets every required criterion of the entry standard."},{"id":"writing-guide","area":"Wording","rule":"The summary and note follow the writing guide."},{"id":"universal-language","area":"Summary and scope","rule":"The summary makes no universal statement (always, never, every, universal, the smell of …)."},{"id":"verification-language","area":"Evidence presentation","rule":"Editorial text does not claim scientific backing (proven, scientifically, studies show, research shows, clinically, verified)."},{"id":"mechanism-wording","area":"Text and evidence","rule":"Editorial text that names a cause, chemical or emitting material is read by an editor against the entry's VERIFIED claims, and the result is recorded."},{"id":"type-summary-fit","area":"Summary and scope","rule":"A place entry's summary describes an environment; a source, material or food entry's summary describes that thing."},{"id":"descriptor-classified","area":"Descriptors","rule":"Every descriptor is classified in the descriptor review, and none is a setting word."},{"id":"descriptor-spelling","area":"Descriptors","rule":"The entry does not use a descriptor whose spelling variant is also in use, until one spelling is chosen."},{"id":"related-valid","area":"Links","rule":"Related entries exist, are not the entry itself and are not repeated."},{"id":"inbound-related","area":"Links","rule":"At least one other entry lists this entry as related, so it can be reached from the Atlas."},{"id":"place-material-direction","area":"Links","rule":"A smellscape-of link starts from a place entry; a produced-by link starts from a material, object, product, state, source or experience entry; every key exists."},{"id":"identity-boundary","area":"Identity","rule":"An entry of the same kind that shares three or more descriptors with another, and is linked with it, has a written boundary (one names the other) or a reviewed distinction."}],"resolutionKinds":{"fixed":"The entry was corrected, with a revision and a change summary.","kept":"An editor read the text; it is accurate as written.","deferred":"Recorded for editorial follow-up; no change now.","open-question":"A subjective editorial choice recorded as an open question, not decided here."},"summary":{"entries":200,"meetingStandard":200,"checks":12,"entriesWithFindings":56,"findings":60,"findingsByStatus":{"kept":15,"open-question":8,"deferred":37,"fixed":3},"findingsByCheck":{"entry-standard":{},"writing-guide":{},"universal-language":{},"verification-language":{},"mechanism-wording":{"kept":15,"deferred":1,"fixed":3},"type-summary-fit":{},"descriptor-classified":{},"descriptor-spelling":{"open-question":8},"related-valid":{},"inbound-related":{"deferred":36},"place-material-direction":{},"identity-boundary":{}},"open":0,"revisedInBaseline":75,"entriesWithSettingWords":72,"correctionNotices":["COR-0004","COR-0005","COR-0006"],"lookAlikePairs":47,"lookAlikePairsWithWrittenBoundary":8,"reviewedBoundaries":39},"descriptors":{"boundary":"Descriptors describe how something smells. Words that name a place, category, time or use are shown as the entry's setting instead. Words outside the curated vocabulary are not errors: they are listed for editorial review, and adding a word to the vocabulary is an editorial decision.","kinds":{"canonical":"One of the curated SmellBook descriptors.","quality":"A smell quality outside the curated vocabulary; a vocabulary candidate for editorial review.","source-reference":"A descriptor named after a familiar source, as smell description commonly does.","cross-modal":"An accepted cross-sense word in smell description; descriptive, not a measurement.","setting":"Names a place, category, time, use or social context rather than a smell quality; shown as the entry's setting, not as a descriptor."},"words":{"canonical":["animalic","bitter","chemical","citrus","clean","cool","creamy","dry","earthy","fabric","fermented","floral","fresh","fruity","grain","green","herbal","industrial","marine","metallic","mineral","paper","powdery","pungent","resinous","roasted","salty","smoky","soft","spicy","stored","sweet","tangy","tropical","warm","waxy","woody"],"quality":["acidic","aged","airy","alkaline","aromatic","baked","browned","burnt","buttery","caramelized","concentrated","cooked","cosmetic","dairy","damp","dusty","fried","grassy","humid","inky","juicy","leafy","minty","mixed","moist","musky","nutty","organic","papery","petal","rubbery","savory","savoury","sharp","sour","stale","starchy","sulfurous","sweet-solvent","synthetic","tannic","tart","toasted","volatile","watery","wet"],"source-reference":["cocoa","coffee","concrete","hay","molasses","plastic","soap","steam","vanilla","water"],"cross-modal":["bright","cold","dark","fuzzy","lush","minimal","muted","rich","subtle"],"setting":["activity","ambient","busy","clinical","construction","domestic","enclosed","familiar","food","hospitality","indoor","interior","manufactured","market","material","morning","new","office","outdoors","personal","polished","product","quiet","rainy","retail","ritual","school","shared","social","sport","summer","transit","urban","work","workshop"]},"spellingVariants":[["savory","savoury"]]},"identityBoundaries":[{"a":"cedar","b":"pine-needles","aName":"Cedar","bName":"Pine Needles","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"bergamot","b":"orange-peel","aName":"Bergamot","bName":"Orange Peel","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"lemon-zest","b":"orange-peel","aName":"Lemon Zest","bName":"Orange Peel","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"grapefruit-peel","b":"orange-peel","aName":"Grapefruit Peel","bName":"Orange Peel","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"grapefruit-peel","b":"lemon-zest","aName":"Grapefruit Peel","bName":"Lemon Zest","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"lilac","b":"rose","aName":"Lilac","bName":"Rose","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"jasmine","b":"lilac","aName":"Jasmine","bName":"Lilac","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"gardenia","b":"jasmine","aName":"Gardenia","bName":"Jasmine","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"chamomile","b":"lavender","aName":"Chamomile","bName":"Lavender","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"banana","b":"vanilla-bean","aName":"Banana","bName":"Vanilla Bean","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"coconut","b":"vanilla-bean","aName":"Coconut","bName":"Vanilla Bean","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"banana","b":"coconut","aName":"Banana","bName":"Coconut","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"basil","b":"mint","aName":"Basil","bName":"Mint","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"cinnamon","b":"clove","aName":"Cinnamon","bName":"Clove","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"cinnamon","b":"nutmeg","aName":"Cinnamon","bName":"Nutmeg","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"clove","b":"nutmeg","aName":"Clove","bName":"Nutmeg","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"black-pepper","b":"nutmeg","aName":"Black Pepper","bName":"Nutmeg","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"garlic","b":"onion","aName":"Garlic","bName":"Onion","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"apple","b":"strawberry","aName":"Apple","bName":"Strawberry","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"apple","b":"pear","aName":"Apple","bName":"Pear","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"apple","b":"watermelon","aName":"Apple","bName":"Watermelon","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"apple","b":"grape","aName":"Apple","bName":"Grape","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"strawberry","b":"watermelon","aName":"Strawberry","bName":"Watermelon","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"grape","b":"pear","aName":"Grape","bName":"Pear","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"mango","b":"peach","aName":"Mango","bName":"Peach","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"mango","b":"pineapple","aName":"Mango","bName":"Pineapple","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"rosemary","b":"sage","aName":"Rosemary","bName":"Sage","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"rosemary","b":"thyme","aName":"Rosemary","bName":"Thyme","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"sage","b":"thyme","aName":"Sage","bName":"Thyme","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"fresh-orange-juice","b":"lemonade","aName":"Fresh Orange Juice","bName":"Lemonade","reason":"different-source","explanation":"Different named sources (different plants, fruits, spices or foods)."},{"a":"pine-needles","b":"pine-resin","aName":"Pine Needles","bName":"Pine Resin","reason":"different-part","explanation":"Different parts or materials of the same plant."},{"a":"garden-after-rain","b":"rainy-park","aName":"Garden After Rain","bName":"Rainy Park","reason":"different-place","explanation":"Different kinds of place, each with its own setting."},{"a":"bookstore","b":"classroom","aName":"Bookstore","bName":"Classroom","reason":"different-place","explanation":"Different kinds of place, each with its own setting."},{"a":"farmers-market","b":"supermarket-produce","aName":"Farmers Market","bName":"Supermarket Produce","reason":"different-place","explanation":"Different kinds of place, each with its own setting."},{"a":"fresh-laundry","b":"soap","aName":"Fresh Laundry","bName":"Soap","reason":"different-product","explanation":"Different product categories used in different routines."},{"a":"fresh-towels","b":"soap","aName":"Fresh Towels","bName":"Soap","reason":"different-product","explanation":"Different product categories used in different routines."},{"a":"shampoo","b":"soap","aName":"Shampoo","bName":"Soap","reason":"different-product","explanation":"Different product categories used in different routines."},{"a":"fresh-towels","b":"shampoo","aName":"Fresh Towels","bName":"Shampoo","reason":"different-product","explanation":"Different product categories used in different routines."},{"a":"basil","b":"fresh-herb-bundle","aName":"Basil","bName":"Fresh Herb Bundle","reason":"composite-vs-single","explanation":"One entry is a mix of sources; the other is a single source."}],"relatedObservations":[{"slug":"garlic","related":["toast","bakery"],"note":"Garlic lists Toast and Bakery, which share no setting or quality with it beyond cooking.","name":"Garlic"},{"slug":"mushroom","related":["dark-chocolate"],"note":"Mushroom lists Dark Chocolate.","name":"Mushroom"},{"slug":"jasmine","related":["hotel-lobby"],"note":"A source lists a place through fragrance use; may be intended.","name":"Jasmine"},{"slug":"vanilla-bean","related":["hotel-lobby"],"note":"A source lists a place through fragrance use; may be intended.","name":"Vanilla Bean"},{"slug":"orange-peel","related":["rain"],"note":"Orange Peel lists Rain.","name":"Orange Peel"},{"slug":"tomato-leaf","related":["rain"],"note":"Tomato Leaf lists Rain.","name":"Tomato Leaf"},{"slug":"wet-dog","related":["fresh-laundry"],"note":"Wet Dog lists Fresh Laundry.","name":"Wet Dog"}],"openQuestions":[{"id":"spelling","question":"Which spelling should SmellBook use: US (color, flavor, savory, gray) or UK (colour, flavour, savoury, grey)?","evidence":"Live entries mix both: \"color\", \"flavor\" and \"center\" with \"grey\", \"tyre\", \"neighbourhood\"; the descriptor \"savory\" is on 4 entries and \"savoury\" on 4.","effect":"Once chosen, the other spelling is corrected across entries and the descriptor vocabulary."},{"id":"vocabulary-candidates","question":"Which smell-quality words used on live entries should join the curated descriptor vocabulary?","evidence":"46 words used on live entries are smell qualities outside the 37 curated descriptors (for example sharp, wet, damp, toasted, aromatic, dusty). A few words now shown as setting words could also be read as smell qualities (clinical, new, polished); they belong to this question too.","effect":"Each added word gets a descriptor page and links; words not added stay on entries as uncurated qualities."},{"id":"places-and-spaces","question":"Should \"Spaces\" remain a separate category from \"Places\"?","evidence":"Hotel Lobby, Hotel Room and Hotel Bathroom are in Spaces while Hotel Breakfast is in Places; seven entries are in Spaces in all.","effect":"Either the boundary is written down, or the Spaces entries move to Places (category pages and facets change)."}],"entries":[{"recordId":"SB-0001","urn":"smellbook:smell:rain","slug":"rain","name":"Rain","category":"Nature","type":"Phenomenon","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":18,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0002","urn":"smellbook:smell:wet-stone","slug":"wet-stone","name":"Wet Stone","category":"Objects","type":"State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["quiet"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":12,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; quiet is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0003","urn":"smellbook:smell:cedar","slug":"cedar","name":"Cedar","category":"Nature","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":17,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0004","urn":"smellbook:smell:orange-peel","slug":"orange-peel","name":"Orange Peel","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":6,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Peel oils are supported by the entry's VERIFIED claim CLM-CITRUS-001 (volatile essential-oil compounds in the rind)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0005","urn":"smellbook:smell:coffee","slug":"coffee","name":"Coffee","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":13,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0006","urn":"smellbook:smell:rose","slug":"rose","name":"Rose","category":"Nature","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":12,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0007","urn":"smellbook:smell:sea-air","slug":"sea-air","name":"Sea Air","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":2,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":8,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0008","urn":"smellbook:smell:old-book","slug":"old-book","name":"Old Book","category":"Objects","type":"Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":12,"verifiedClaims":2,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0009","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-bread","slug":"fresh-bread","name":"Fresh Bread","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":9,"verifiedClaims":2,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0010","urn":"smellbook:smell:clean-linen","slug":"clean-linen","name":"Clean Linen","category":"Objects","type":"Cultural / Product","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":17,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0011","urn":"smellbook:smell:tomato-leaf","slug":"tomato-leaf","name":"Tomato Leaf","category":"Nature","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":6,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0012","urn":"smellbook:smell:bergamot","slug":"bergamot","name":"Bergamot","category":"Fragrance","type":"Source / Fragrance Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":5,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0013","urn":"smellbook:smell:soil","slug":"soil","name":"Soil","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":11,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0014","urn":"smellbook:smell:pine-needles","slug":"pine-needles","name":"Pine Needles","category":"Nature","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0015","urn":"smellbook:smell:cut-grass","slug":"cut-grass","name":"Cut Grass","category":"Nature","type":"State / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":2,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0016","urn":"smellbook:smell:jasmine","slug":"jasmine","name":"Jasmine","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Fragrance Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0017","urn":"smellbook:smell:lavender","slug":"lavender","name":"Lavender","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Fragrance Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0018","urn":"smellbook:smell:lemon-zest","slug":"lemon-zest","name":"Lemon Zest","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":8,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Peel oil is supported by the entry's VERIFIED claim CLM-CITRUS-001 (volatile essential-oil compounds in the rind)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0019","urn":"smellbook:smell:dark-chocolate","slug":"dark-chocolate","name":"Dark Chocolate","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0020","urn":"smellbook:smell:vanilla-bean","slug":"vanilla-bean","name":"Vanilla Bean","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":11,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0021","urn":"smellbook:smell:wood-smoke","slug":"wood-smoke","name":"Wood Smoke","category":"Phenomena","type":"Phenomenon / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":7,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0022","urn":"smellbook:smell:leather","slug":"leather","name":"Leather","category":"Objects","type":"Material / Cultural Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["material"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":8,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; material is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0023","urn":"smellbook:smell:asphalt-after-rain","slug":"asphalt-after-rain","name":"Asphalt After Rain","category":"Places","type":"State / Place Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["urban"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; urban is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0024","urn":"smellbook:smell:chlorine-pool","slug":"chlorine-pool","name":"Chlorine / Pool","category":"Places","type":"Place / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":2,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"The note says chemistry varies by treatment; it makes no claim about a cause."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0025","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-laundry","slug":"fresh-laundry","name":"Fresh Laundry","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":8,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0026","urn":"smellbook:smell:pine-forest","slug":"pine-forest","name":"Pine Forest","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":7,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0027","urn":"smellbook:smell:bakery","slug":"bakery","name":"Bakery","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":6,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0028","urn":"smellbook:smell:library","slug":"library","name":"Library","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["quiet"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":2,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; quiet is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0029","urn":"smellbook:smell:garden-after-rain","slug":"garden-after-rain","name":"Garden After Rain","category":"Places","type":"Place / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":7,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0030","urn":"smellbook:smell:hotel-lobby","slug":"hotel-lobby","name":"Hotel Lobby","category":"Spaces","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["polished","ambient"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":6,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; polished, ambient are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0031","urn":"smellbook:smell:petrichor","slug":"petrichor","name":"Petrichor","category":"Phenomena","type":"Phenomenon","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0032","urn":"smellbook:smell:mint","slug":"mint","name":"Mint","category":"Nature","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0033","urn":"smellbook:smell:basil","slug":"basil","name":"Basil","category":"Nature","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":6,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0034","urn":"smellbook:smell:eucalyptus","slug":"eucalyptus","name":"Eucalyptus","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Cultural Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0035","urn":"smellbook:smell:cinnamon","slug":"cinnamon","name":"Cinnamon","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":6,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0036","urn":"smellbook:smell:garlic","slug":"garlic","name":"Garlic","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":5,"verifiedClaims":2,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"descriptor-spelling","status":"open-question","note":"\"savory\" and \"savoury\" are both in use; which spelling SmellBook uses is an open editorial question (see the spelling question)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0037","urn":"smellbook:smell:toast","slug":"toast","name":"Toast","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":8,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0038","urn":"smellbook:smell:mushroom","slug":"mushroom","name":"Mushroom","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"descriptor-spelling","status":"open-question","note":"\"savory\" and \"savoury\" are both in use; which spelling SmellBook uses is an open editorial question (see the spelling question)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0039","urn":"smellbook:smell:seaweed","slug":"seaweed","name":"Seaweed","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Coastal Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0040","urn":"smellbook:smell:dust","slug":"dust","name":"Dust","category":"Objects","type":"Material / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":6,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"The note says dust is not one material or chemical source; a negation, not a claim."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0041","urn":"smellbook:smell:new-car","slug":"new-car","name":"New Car","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Place Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["manufactured","material"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":7,"verifiedClaims":2,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; manufactured, material are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Adhesives are listed among the interior materials the smell is associated with, not as a measured cause; the VERIFIED claims concern volatile compounds from interior materials."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0042","urn":"smellbook:smell:gasoline","slug":"gasoline","name":"Gasoline","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Material Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"\"Volatile\" is supported by the entry's VERIFIED claim CLM-GASOLINE-001 (volatile compounds in gasoline vapour)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0043","urn":"smellbook:smell:rubber","slug":"rubber","name":"Rubber","category":"Objects","type":"Material","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":7,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0044","urn":"smellbook:smell:plastic","slug":"plastic","name":"Plastic","category":"Objects","type":"Material","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["material","manufactured"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; material, manufactured are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0045","urn":"smellbook:smell:metal","slug":"metal","name":"Metal","category":"Objects","type":"Material / Perceptual Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":6,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"The note says the entry avoids claiming one metal odour chemistry; a negation, not a claim."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0046","urn":"smellbook:smell:sunscreen","slug":"sunscreen","name":"Sunscreen","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":2,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0047","urn":"smellbook:smell:campfire","slug":"campfire","name":"Campfire","category":"Phenomena","type":"Place / Phenomenon Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["outdoors"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; outdoors is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0048","urn":"smellbook:smell:peppermint","slug":"peppermint","name":"Peppermint","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Cultural Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0049","urn":"smellbook:smell:cinnamon-roll","slug":"cinnamon-roll","name":"Cinnamon Roll","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":5,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0050","urn":"smellbook:smell:subway-metro","slug":"subway-metro","name":"Subway / Metro","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["urban"],"aliases":2,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":8,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; urban is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0051","urn":"smellbook:smell:apple","slug":"apple","name":"Apple","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":9,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0052","urn":"smellbook:smell:banana","slug":"banana","name":"Banana","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0053","urn":"smellbook:smell:strawberry","slug":"strawberry","name":"Strawberry","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":7,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0054","urn":"smellbook:smell:butter","slug":"butter","name":"Butter","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Material","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":5,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0055","urn":"smellbook:smell:cheese","slug":"cheese","name":"Cheese","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"descriptor-spelling","status":"open-question","note":"\"savory\" and \"savoury\" are both in use; which spelling SmellBook uses is an open editorial question (see the spelling question)."},{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0056","urn":"smellbook:smell:onion","slug":"onion","name":"Onion","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"descriptor-spelling","status":"open-question","note":"\"savory\" and \"savoury\" are both in use; which spelling SmellBook uses is an open editorial question (see the spelling question)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0057","urn":"smellbook:smell:vinegar","slug":"vinegar","name":"Vinegar","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Product","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0058","urn":"smellbook:smell:black-tea","slug":"black-tea","name":"Black Tea","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0059","urn":"smellbook:smell:honey","slug":"honey","name":"Honey","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Natural Product","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":6,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0060","urn":"smellbook:smell:coconut","slug":"coconut","name":"Coconut","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0061","urn":"smellbook:smell:moss","slug":"moss","name":"Moss","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0062","urn":"smellbook:smell:hay","slug":"hay","name":"Hay","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Agricultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0063","urn":"smellbook:smell:snow-cold-air","slug":"snow-cold-air","name":"Snow / Cold Air","category":"Phenomena","type":"Phenomenon / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0064","urn":"smellbook:smell:lilac","slug":"lilac","name":"Lilac","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Floral Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0065","urn":"smellbook:smell:gardenia","slug":"gardenia","name":"Gardenia","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Floral Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0066","urn":"smellbook:smell:chamomile","slug":"chamomile","name":"Chamomile","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Herbal Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0067","urn":"smellbook:smell:soap","slug":"soap","name":"Soap","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["product"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":13,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; product is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0068","urn":"smellbook:smell:toothpaste","slug":"toothpaste","name":"Toothpaste","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0069","urn":"smellbook:smell:new-paint","slug":"new-paint","name":"New Paint","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Place Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["manufactured"],"aliases":2,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; manufactured is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Solvents and coatings are listed as what the smell is associated with, not as a measured cause; the note discourages inhaling them."},{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Solvents and coatings are listed as what the smell is associated with, not as a measured cause; the note discourages inhaling them."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0070","urn":"smellbook:smell:wet-dog","slug":"wet-dog","name":"Wet Dog","category":"Animals","type":"Animal / State Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Summary no longer names skin oils as part of the smell, which no VERIFIED claim on the entry supports.","correctionId":"COR-0004","findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0071","urn":"smellbook:smell:bookstore","slug":"bookstore","name":"Bookstore","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["quiet"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; quiet is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0072","urn":"smellbook:smell:garage","slug":"garage","name":"Garage","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0073","urn":"smellbook:smell:cinema-popcorn","slug":"cinema-popcorn","name":"Cinema Popcorn","category":"Places","type":"Place / Food Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0074","urn":"smellbook:smell:church-incense","slug":"church-incense","name":"Church Incense","category":"Places","type":"Place / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["ritual"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":2,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; ritual is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0075","urn":"smellbook:smell:morning-kitchen","slug":"morning-kitchen","name":"Morning Kitchen","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["food","familiar"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":5,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; food, familiar are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0076","urn":"smellbook:smell:pencil-shavings","slug":"pencil-shavings","name":"Pencil Shavings","category":"Objects","type":"Material / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["familiar"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; familiar is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0077","urn":"smellbook:smell:newspaper","slug":"newspaper","name":"Newspaper","category":"Objects","type":"Object / Material Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["familiar"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; familiar is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0078","urn":"smellbook:smell:cardboard","slug":"cardboard","name":"Cardboard","category":"Objects","type":"Material","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":10,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"deferred","note":"The note says the smell changes with ink, adhesives, moisture and storage. Moisture is supported by CLM-CARDBOARD-001; ink and adhesives are not. Recorded for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0079","urn":"smellbook:smell:candle-wax","slug":"candle-wax","name":"Candle Wax","category":"Objects","type":"Material / Product","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0080","urn":"smellbook:smell:fireplace","slug":"fireplace","name":"Fireplace","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["domestic"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; domestic is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0081","urn":"smellbook:smell:wet-wool","slug":"wet-wool","name":"Wet Wool","category":"Objects","type":"Material / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0082","urn":"smellbook:smell:cotton","slug":"cotton","name":"Cotton","category":"Objects","type":"Material / Cultural Reference","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":10,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0083","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-towels","slug":"fresh-towels","name":"Fresh Towels","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":9,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0084","urn":"smellbook:smell:shampoo","slug":"shampoo","name":"Shampoo","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0085","urn":"smellbook:smell:baby-powder","slug":"baby-powder","name":"Baby Powder","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0086","urn":"smellbook:smell:skin","slug":"skin","name":"Skin","category":"Body","type":"Body / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["personal"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; personal is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0087","urn":"smellbook:smell:hair","slug":"hair","name":"Hair","category":"Body","type":"Body / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["personal"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; personal is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0088","urn":"smellbook:smell:cat-fur","slug":"cat-fur","name":"Cat Fur","category":"Animals","type":"Animal / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Summary no longer names skin oils as part of the smell, which no VERIFIED claim on the entry supports.","correctionId":"COR-0005","findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0089","urn":"smellbook:smell:ocean-spray","slug":"ocean-spray","name":"Ocean Spray","category":"Nature","type":"Phenomenon / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0090","urn":"smellbook:smell:hot-pavement","slug":"hot-pavement","name":"Hot Pavement","category":"Places","type":"Place / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["urban"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; urban is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0091","urn":"smellbook:smell:airport","slug":"airport","name":"Airport","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["transit","ambient"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; transit, ambient are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0092","urn":"smellbook:smell:supermarket-produce","slug":"supermarket-produce","name":"Supermarket Produce","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["retail"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; retail is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0093","urn":"smellbook:smell:laundromat","slug":"laundromat","name":"Laundromat","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0094","urn":"smellbook:smell:classroom","slug":"classroom","name":"Classroom","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["familiar"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":5,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; familiar is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0095","urn":"smellbook:smell:hotel-room","slug":"hotel-room","name":"Hotel Room","category":"Spaces","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["ambient"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; ambient is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0096","urn":"smellbook:smell:florist-shop","slug":"florist-shop","name":"Florist Shop","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0097","urn":"smellbook:smell:farmers-market","slug":"farmers-market","name":"Farmers Market","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["food"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; food is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0098","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-wood","slug":"fresh-wood","name":"Fresh Wood","category":"Objects","type":"Material / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":7,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0099","urn":"smellbook:smell:new-shoes","slug":"new-shoes","name":"New Shoes","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["new","material","manufactured"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; new, material, manufactured are now shown as the entry's setting; synthetic added from the entry's own summary.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Adhesives are listed among the materials of new footwear, not as a measured cause."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0100","urn":"smellbook:smell:tennis-ball","slug":"tennis-ball","name":"Tennis Ball","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Material Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["new","sport"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; new, sport are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0101","urn":"smellbook:smell:pine-resin","slug":"pine-resin","name":"Pine Resin","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Material","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Resin is the entry's own subject; its VERIFIED claim CLM-PINERESIN-001 describes the resin's composition."},{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Resin is the entry's own subject; its VERIFIED claim CLM-PINERESIN-001 describes the resin's composition."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0102","urn":"smellbook:smell:oak-wood","slug":"oak-wood","name":"Oak Wood","category":"Nature","type":"Material / Source","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["material"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; material is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0103","urn":"smellbook:smell:cork","slug":"cork","name":"Cork","category":"Objects","type":"Material","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["material"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; material is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0104","urn":"smellbook:smell:clay","slug":"clay","name":"Clay","category":"Nature","type":"Material / Earth","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0105","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-concrete","slug":"fresh-concrete","name":"Fresh Concrete","category":"Objects","type":"Material / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["construction"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; construction is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0106","urn":"smellbook:smell:rain-on-concrete","slug":"rain-on-concrete","name":"Rain on Concrete","category":"Places","type":"State / Place Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["urban"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; urban is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0107","urn":"smellbook:smell:autumn-leaves","slug":"autumn-leaves","name":"Autumn Leaves","category":"Nature","type":"Seasonal / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0108","urn":"smellbook:smell:dry-leaves","slug":"dry-leaves","name":"Dry Leaves","category":"Nature","type":"Material / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0109","urn":"smellbook:smell:greenhouse","slug":"greenhouse","name":"Greenhouse","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0110","urn":"smellbook:smell:flower-market","slug":"flower-market","name":"Flower Market","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["market"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; market is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0111","urn":"smellbook:smell:wet-forest","slug":"wet-forest","name":"Wet Forest","category":"Places","type":"Place / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0112","urn":"smellbook:smell:hair-salon","slug":"hair-salon","name":"Hair Salon","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["product"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; product is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0113","urn":"smellbook:smell:vintage-clothing-shop","slug":"vintage-clothing-shop","name":"Vintage Clothing Shop","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0114","urn":"smellbook:smell:museum","slug":"museum","name":"Museum","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["quiet","material","ambient"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; quiet, material, ambient are now shown as the entry's setting; paper added from the entry's own summary.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0115","urn":"smellbook:smell:old-church","slug":"old-church","name":"Old Church","category":"Places","type":"Place / Cultural Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["ritual"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; ritual is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0116","urn":"smellbook:smell:hospital-corridor","slug":"hospital-corridor","name":"Hospital Corridor","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["clinical","ambient"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; clinical, ambient are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0117","urn":"smellbook:smell:train-carriage","slug":"train-carriage","name":"Train Carriage","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["transit","ambient"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; transit, ambient are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0118","urn":"smellbook:smell:airplane-cabin","slug":"airplane-cabin","name":"Airplane Cabin","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["transit","ambient"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; transit, ambient are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0119","urn":"smellbook:smell:taxi-interior","slug":"taxi-interior","name":"Taxi Interior","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["urban","ambient","manufactured"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; urban, ambient, manufactured are now shown as the entry's setting; plastic added from the entry's own summary.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0120","urn":"smellbook:smell:hotel-breakfast","slug":"hotel-breakfast","name":"Hotel Breakfast","category":"Places","type":"Place / Food Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["food","hospitality"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; food, hospitality are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0121","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-milk","slug":"fresh-milk","name":"Fresh Milk","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0122","urn":"smellbook:smell:yogurt","slug":"yogurt","name":"Yogurt","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0123","urn":"smellbook:smell:peanut-butter","slug":"peanut-butter","name":"Peanut Butter","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Product","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0124","urn":"smellbook:smell:almond","slug":"almond","name":"Almond","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0125","urn":"smellbook:smell:peach","slug":"peach","name":"Peach","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0126","urn":"smellbook:smell:pear","slug":"pear","name":"Pear","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0127","urn":"smellbook:smell:grapefruit-peel","slug":"grapefruit-peel","name":"Grapefruit Peel","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Note no longer attributes the smell to rind oils, which no VERIFIED claim on the entry supports.","correctionId":"COR-0006","findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0128","urn":"smellbook:smell:watermelon","slug":"watermelon","name":"Watermelon","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0129","urn":"smellbook:smell:rosemary","slug":"rosemary","name":"Rosemary","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Herb","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0130","urn":"smellbook:smell:sage","slug":"sage","name":"Sage","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Herb","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0131","urn":"smellbook:smell:thyme","slug":"thyme","name":"Thyme","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Herb","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"descriptor-spelling","status":"open-question","note":"\"savory\" and \"savoury\" are both in use; which spelling SmellBook uses is an open editorial question (see the spelling question)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0132","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-corn","slug":"fresh-corn","name":"Fresh Corn","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0133","urn":"smellbook:smell:tomato-sauce","slug":"tomato-sauce","name":"Tomato Sauce","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"descriptor-spelling","status":"open-question","note":"\"savory\" and \"savoury\" are both in use; which spelling SmellBook uses is an open editorial question (see the spelling question)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0134","urn":"smellbook:smell:fried-onions","slug":"fried-onions","name":"Fried Onions","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"descriptor-spelling","status":"open-question","note":"\"savory\" and \"savoury\" are both in use; which spelling SmellBook uses is an open editorial question (see the spelling question)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0135","urn":"smellbook:smell:grilled-bread","slug":"grilled-bread","name":"Grilled Bread","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0136","urn":"smellbook:smell:maple-syrup","slug":"maple-syrup","name":"Maple Syrup","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Product","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0137","urn":"smellbook:smell:cocoa-powder","slug":"cocoa-powder","name":"Cocoa Powder","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Material","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0138","urn":"smellbook:smell:cold-metal-rail","slug":"cold-metal-rail","name":"Cold Metal Rail","category":"Objects","type":"Material / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["material"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; material is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0139","urn":"smellbook:smell:warm-electronics","slug":"warm-electronics","name":"Warm Electronics","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["manufactured"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; manufactured is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0140","urn":"smellbook:smell:printer-paper","slug":"printer-paper","name":"Printer Paper","category":"Objects","type":"Material / Office Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["office"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; office is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0141","urn":"smellbook:smell:pencil-case","slug":"pencil-case","name":"Pencil Case","category":"Objects","type":"Object / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["school","material","familiar"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; school, material, familiar are now shown as the entry's setting; plastic added from the entry's own summary.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0142","urn":"smellbook:smell:coffee-shop","slug":"coffee-shop","name":"Coffee Shop","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["social"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; social is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0143","urn":"smellbook:smell:office","slug":"office","name":"Office","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["ambient","work"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; ambient, work are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0144","urn":"smellbook:smell:elevator","slug":"elevator","name":"Elevator","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["enclosed","ambient"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; enclosed, ambient are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0145","urn":"smellbook:smell:beach-towel","slug":"beach-towel","name":"Beach Towel","category":"Objects","type":"Object / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["summer"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; summer is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0146","urn":"smellbook:smell:sports-hall","slug":"sports-hall","name":"Sports Hall","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["indoor","activity"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; indoor, activity are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0147","urn":"smellbook:smell:stable","slug":"stable","name":"Stable","category":"Places","type":"Place / Animal Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0148","urn":"smellbook:smell:rainy-bus-stop","slug":"rainy-bus-stop","name":"Rainy Bus Stop","category":"Places","type":"Place / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["urban"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; urban is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0149","urn":"smellbook:smell:old-attic","slug":"old-attic","name":"Old Attic","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0150","urn":"smellbook:smell:freshly-cleaned-room","slug":"freshly-cleaned-room","name":"Freshly Cleaned Room","category":"Spaces","type":"Place / Cultural Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["product"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; product is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0151","urn":"smellbook:smell:pineapple","slug":"pineapple","name":"Pineapple","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0152","urn":"smellbook:smell:mango","slug":"mango","name":"Mango","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0153","urn":"smellbook:smell:grape","slug":"grape","name":"Grape","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0154","urn":"smellbook:smell:cherry","slug":"cherry","name":"Cherry","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0155","urn":"smellbook:smell:ginger","slug":"ginger","name":"Ginger","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Food","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0156","urn":"smellbook:smell:clove","slug":"clove","name":"Clove","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Spice","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0157","urn":"smellbook:smell:nutmeg","slug":"nutmeg","name":"Nutmeg","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Spice","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0158","urn":"smellbook:smell:black-pepper","slug":"black-pepper","name":"Black Pepper","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Source / Spice","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":4,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0159","urn":"smellbook:smell:cooked-rice","slug":"cooked-rice","name":"Cooked Rice","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0160","urn":"smellbook:smell:popcorn","slug":"popcorn","name":"Popcorn","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0161","urn":"smellbook:smell:caramel","slug":"caramel","name":"Caramel","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0162","urn":"smellbook:smell:burnt-toast","slug":"burnt-toast","name":"Burnt Toast","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Overheated State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0163","urn":"smellbook:smell:woodshop","slug":"woodshop","name":"Woodshop","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["workshop"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; workshop is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Resin is listed among the materials of a workshop, not as a measured cause."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0164","urn":"smellbook:smell:detergent","slug":"detergent","name":"Detergent","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["product"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; product is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0165","urn":"smellbook:smell:dish-soap","slug":"dish-soap","name":"Dish Soap","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["product"],"aliases":2,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; product is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0166","urn":"smellbook:smell:hand-sanitizer","slug":"hand-sanitizer","name":"Hand Sanitizer","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Cultural Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["product"],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; product is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"\"Alcohol-like volatility\" describes the quick-evaporating impression as an association, not a measured cause."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0167","urn":"smellbook:smell:pharmacy","slug":"pharmacy","name":"Pharmacy","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["retail","clinical"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; retail, clinical are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0168","urn":"smellbook:smell:restaurant-kitchen","slug":"restaurant-kitchen","name":"Restaurant Kitchen","category":"Places","type":"Place / Food Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["food","busy"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; food, busy are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"descriptor-spelling","status":"open-question","note":"\"savory\" and \"savoury\" are both in use; which spelling SmellBook uses is an open editorial question (see the spelling question)."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0169","urn":"smellbook:smell:bus-interior","slug":"bus-interior","name":"Bus Interior","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["transit","ambient"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; transit, ambient are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0170","urn":"smellbook:smell:tram-interior","slug":"tram-interior","name":"Tram Interior","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":1,"settingWords":["transit","urban","ambient"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; transit, urban, ambient are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0171","urn":"smellbook:smell:rainy-park","slug":"rainy-park","name":"Rainy Park","category":"Places","type":"Place / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0172","urn":"smellbook:smell:summer-garden","slug":"summer-garden","name":"Summer Garden","category":"Places","type":"Place / Seasonal Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["summer"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; summer is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0173","urn":"smellbook:smell:winter-coat","slug":"winter-coat","name":"Winter Coat","category":"Objects","type":"Object / Seasonal Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":3,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0174","urn":"smellbook:smell:new-apartment","slug":"new-apartment","name":"New Apartment","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":1,"settingWords":["new","material","interior"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":2,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; new, material, interior are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0175","urn":"smellbook:smell:old-basement","slug":"old-basement","name":"Old Basement","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":2,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0176","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-orange-juice","slug":"fresh-orange-juice","name":"Fresh Orange Juice","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0177","urn":"smellbook:smell:lemonade","slug":"lemonade","name":"Lemonade","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0178","urn":"smellbook:smell:vanilla-ice-cream","slug":"vanilla-ice-cream","name":"Vanilla Ice Cream","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0179","urn":"smellbook:smell:baked-apple","slug":"baked-apple","name":"Baked Apple","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0180","urn":"smellbook:smell:toasted-almonds","slug":"toasted-almonds","name":"Toasted Almonds","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Prepared State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0181","urn":"smellbook:smell:brown-sugar","slug":"brown-sugar","name":"Brown Sugar","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Material","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0182","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-herb-bundle","slug":"fresh-herb-bundle","name":"Fresh Herb Bundle","category":"Nature","type":"Source / Mixed Botanical","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0183","urn":"smellbook:smell:curry-spice-blend","slug":"curry-spice-blend","name":"Curry Spice Blend","category":"Food & Drink","type":"Food / Composition","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0184","urn":"smellbook:smell:wet-cardboard","slug":"wet-cardboard","name":"Wet Cardboard","category":"Objects","type":"Material / State","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0185","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-carpet","slug":"fresh-carpet","name":"Fresh Carpet","category":"Objects","type":"Material / Product Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":1,"settingWords":["new","manufactured","interior"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; new, manufactured, interior are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"mechanism-wording","status":"kept","note":"Backing and adhesives are listed as parts of new flooring; the VERIFIED claim CLM-CARPET-001 attributes the new-carpet odour to the latex backing."},{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0186","urn":"smellbook:smell:new-furniture","slug":"new-furniture","name":"New Furniture","category":"Objects","type":"Product / Material Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["new","material","interior"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":1,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; new, material, interior are now shown as the entry's setting; fabric added from the entry's own summary.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0187","urn":"smellbook:smell:hardware-store","slug":"hardware-store","name":"Hardware Store","category":"Places","type":"Place / Retail Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["material","retail"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; material, retail are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0188","urn":"smellbook:smell:parking-garage","slug":"parking-garage","name":"Parking Garage","category":"Places","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["urban"],"aliases":2,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; urban is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0189","urn":"smellbook:smell:kitchen-sink","slug":"kitchen-sink","name":"Kitchen Sink","category":"Spaces","type":"Place / Domestic Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["domestic"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; domestic is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0190","urn":"smellbook:smell:dishwasher-steam","slug":"dishwasher-steam","name":"Dishwasher Steam","category":"Spaces","type":"Domestic / State Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0191","urn":"smellbook:smell:fresh-bedsheets","slug":"fresh-bedsheets","name":"Fresh Bedsheets","category":"Objects","type":"Textile / Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":1,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0192","urn":"smellbook:smell:ironed-shirt","slug":"ironed-shirt","name":"Ironed Shirt","category":"Objects","type":"Textile / State Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0193","urn":"smellbook:smell:raincoat","slug":"raincoat","name":"Raincoat","category":"Objects","type":"Object / Weather Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["material","rainy"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; material, rainy are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0194","urn":"smellbook:smell:umbrella-after-rain","slug":"umbrella-after-rain","name":"Umbrella After Rain","category":"Objects","type":"Object / State Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":1,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[]},{"recordId":"SB-0195","urn":"smellbook:smell:backpack","slug":"backpack","name":"Backpack","category":"Objects","type":"Object / Personal Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["familiar"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; familiar is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0196","urn":"smellbook:smell:school-cafeteria","slug":"school-cafeteria","name":"School Cafeteria","category":"Places","type":"Place / Food Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["food","shared","school"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; food, shared, school are now shown as the entry's setting; cooked added from the entry's own summary.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0197","urn":"smellbook:smell:hotel-bathroom","slug":"hotel-bathroom","name":"Hotel Bathroom","category":"Spaces","type":"Place / Environment","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":3,"settingWords":["hospitality"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; hospitality is now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0198","urn":"smellbook:smell:open-window-after-rain","slug":"open-window-after-rain","name":"Open Window After Rain","category":"Spaces","type":"Place / Atmospheric Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":4,"settingWords":[],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":false,"baselineChange":null,"correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0199","urn":"smellbook:smell:morning-street","slug":"morning-street","name":"Morning Street","category":"Places","type":"Place / Time Experience","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["morning","urban","food"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; morning, urban, food are now shown as the entry's setting; cool added from the entry's own summary.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]},{"recordId":"SB-0200","urn":"smellbook:smell:grocery-bakery-aisle","slug":"grocery-bakery-aisle","name":"Grocery Bakery Aisle","category":"Places","type":"Place / Food Retail","meetsStandard":true,"descriptors":2,"settingWords":["retail","food"],"aliases":0,"relatedOut":3,"relatedIn":0,"verifiedClaims":0,"revisedInBaseline":true,"baselineChange":"Descriptors limited to smell qualities; retail, food are now shown as the entry's setting.","correctionId":null,"findings":[{"check":"inbound-related","status":"deferred","note":"Reachable from its category, descriptor and search pages. Related lists are editorial navigation; which entries should list it is left for editorial follow-up."}]}]}}